A Better St. Louis. Powered by Journalism.
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Print
  • Email

'Advanced technology for data-driven schools'

In Commentary

12:25 am on Mon, 06.18.12

Raise your hand if you can tell me how many K-12 schools are using Accelerated Reader ™, a reading and assessment software package produced by Renaissance Learning™, a company owned since 2011 by Permira Funds, a U.K.-based global private equity management firm with about $20 billion in assets.

Anyone?

The answer is 70,000, nearly half of all U.S. schools. Here in Missouri, thousands of schools, and by extension the millions of taxpayers who support our schools, as well as the families of independent schools who have bought the Accelerated Reading package, are paying customers of Renaissance Learning.

At this very moment, thanks to an animated widget, I know that today alone, children using Accelerated Reader have read 29,260 books made up of 367,084,165 words. These numbers increase (and are monitored) by the second. In the time it takes my fingers to type them, they have changed.

Actually, according to a helpful and solititous Renaissance Learning person I spoke with recently, these numbers reflect the numbers of books (and words) based on which children have passed quizzes with a score of 80 percent or higher. Needless to say, as Renaissance Learning avers on its website (renlearn.com), this is a company that sells "advanced technology for data-driven schools."

What happens is that the company assigns points to the 150,000 books among their quizzable collection, lower numbers for picture books and higher numbers for texts of higher linguistic (if not multimodal) complexity. The company has developed an Advanced TASA Open Standard for Readability (ATOS), which they use to inform an "ATOS readability analyzer," a tool they say helps teachers, who may wonder about the "level" of a classroom text. Renaissance Learning says that its ATOS readability analyzer "makes it easy to get the answers fast."

So children select books that have been determined to be at the appropriate level. Their reading is "managed" and monitored through the software. Quizzes are provided and graded and made available to classroom teachers immediately, with widgets tracking these numbers at each school. Children are encouraged to earn lots of points, even if it means selecting books they are less interested in, because points translate into stickers, treats, and what I have heard kids call "AR parties."

If this all sounds behaviorist, Pavlovian, and dystopian, more like “A Clockwork Orange” than like, say, reading books, that is because it is. Although my sense is that certain well-meaning believers in and employees of Renaissance Learning think they really are serving the needs of children, I also believe that a great many other people -- those who rely on techno-jargon, psychometrical mania and transnational capitalism -- have identified and made profitable use of an ever-growing and available, ever-needy crop of vulnerable and available customers: other people's children and their teachers.

Don't believe me? Here's copy off Renaissance Learning's parent company's website (permira.com):

"More than 1.5 million tests are taken every school day on a Renaissance product. … With strong market positioning, high recurring revenues and significant growth and transformational potential, the Permira funds will draw upon the expertise of Permira’s long-established TMT sector to back an exciting growth strategy opportunity that capitalises on long-term secular trends in education technology."

You may not know what a "TMT sector" is or what a TMT sector has to do with a third grader reading “James and the Giant Peach” in Potosi. I didn't either. The companies purchased by Permira are divided into sectors: Consumer, Industrials, Healthcare, Financial Services and TMT. Renaissance Learning falls under TMT, which stands for "Technology, Media, and Telecommunications.” One of the biggest motivators for Permira to initiate negotiations to buy Renaissance Learnin in the first place was the profit the Wisconsin-based company has sustained since its 1985 founding, this in spite of the ever-shrinking state, federal, and local budgets allocated to education.

Financially pinched and politically frightened, school leaders and education policymakers turn to the non-messy business of squeezing numbers out of kids; in doing so, global private equity firms squeeze dollars out of classrooms and public treasuries. For some people, sorting, managing, monitoring and testing children is very, very profitable.

Renita Schmidt, a former fourth grade teacher, has analyzed in the journal Language Arts the actual effects and outcomes of Accelerated Reader. Back in 2008, Schmidt wrote,

"According to the website, schools that already own a “desktop version of AR” are charged one flat fee for access ($599 in 2007; schools that own a “Renaissance version” are charged no additional fee, but all schools are charged “an annual student fee of $1,000 for 250 students or $4 a student” to access “Accelerated Reader Software,” (more than 100,000 AR quizzes), “9 hours of Web-based Professional Development,” and other support materials listed as professional development or technical support systems." No doubt these numbers have gone up, and I will leave it to others to do the math, but I can tell you that Permira paid close to half a billion dollars (328 million euros, or $413,148,709) to add the company to its TMT roster.

Linking its program to Common Core Standards, to Missouri's own MAP test, and to various other standards, rubrics and benchmarks around the country, Renaissance Learning keeps itself an essential part of the current reformers' unquenchable thirst for measurements and statistics. Not to mention an essential factor in the dehumanization of children and deprofessionalization of the classroom teacher.

Peering through the glass darkly, the kids are the ones generating all these data, the kids who are providing a service to Permira's investers. Maybe they should be the ones charging a fee to Renaissance Learning and all the other education monetizers and commodifiers for the right to collect all these millions and millions of quizzes. People who have to sit for dumbed-down quizzes and high-stakes tests (and their families) should be paid for doing so, since it's always someone else who profits in the kind of data-driven world that "makes it easy to get the answers fast."

Inda Schaenen is a teacher and writer in St. Louis.

 

2 Comments

Join The Beacon

When you register with the Beacon, you can save your searches as news alerts, rsvp for events, manage your donations and receive news and updates from the Beacon team.

Register Now

Already a Member

Getting around the new site

Take a look at our tutorials to help you get the hang of the new site.

Most Discussed Articles By Beacon Members

Conference of American nuns will mull response to Vatican charges

In Nation

7:55 am on Fri, 08.03.12

Meeting in St. Louis next week, the Leadership Conference of Women Religious will have its first opportunity as an assembled group to consider what to do after the Vatican issued a mandate for change this spring. It calls on the conference to reorganize and more strictly observe church teachings.

The 'free' Zoo

In Commentary

7:51 am on Tue, 05.22.12

When a family of four goes to the St. Louis Zoo, they can be forgiven for not knowing it will cost them $60, $72 if they park. If they can't pay, the alternative is to tell the kids they can't do what kids do at the zoo.

Featured Articles

Teacher-prep programs get poor grades in new survey

In Education

4:30 pm on Tue, 06.18.13

Some in Missouri and Illinois were singled out for excellence; others were branded with a consumer alert, that would-be teachers should be wary. The national group that did the survey said it will be repeated annually, said the evaluating group's president Kate Walsh.

At Brandenburg Gate, Obama follows in predecessors' footsteps

In World

3:55 pm on Tue, 06.18.13

Fifty years ago this week, President John F. Kennedy confronted Cold War tensions in Wall-divided Berlin and bolstered the confidence of its beleaguered residents by telling them, "Ich bin ein Berliner." On Wednesday, President Barack Obama will face eastward from the Brandenburg Gate for the latest address of an American president in the city that has been a flashpoint of East-West relations.

Featured Articles

Farewell to Duff's from one who knew it well

In Out & About

12:42 am on Tue, 06.18.13

Duff's, a mainstay of the Central West End since Karen Duffy opened it in 1972, is closing its doors this month. Over the years, Duff's developed a reputation for reasonably priced, imaginative menus and a good selection of wines. But what made Duff's invaluable were the poetry readings on Monday evenings.

Featured Articles

Recent Articles

More Articles

Innovation and entrepreneurial activity are on the rise in St. Louis, especially in bioscience, technology and alternative energy. The Beacon's InnovationSTL section focuses on the people who are part of this wave, what they're doing and how this is shaping our future. To many St. Louisans, this wave is not yet visible. InnovationSTL aims to change that. We welcome you to share your knowledge, learn more about this vibrant trend and discuss its impact.

Featured Articles

Can Facebook and romance mix? Study suggests hazards

In Education

6:10 am on Mon, 06.17.13

Recent research out of Mizzou suggests that excessive use of Facebook can have negative effects on romantic relationships, including cheating, breaking up and divorce. The negative impact tends to be on newer relations, under three years duration. Doctoral student Russell Clayton advocates more moderate Facebook use to prevent its threats.

Featured Articles

Bosley right to put child first - but not to ask others to pay

In Commentary

12:39 am on Tue, 06.18.13

Asking for contributions for a child’s college education is legal in Missouri. But not right. Because a parent should help his or her children in almost any way they can,  such obligations must be kept far away from a politician’s public responsibilities — it is not hard to figure out which one would lose if they conflicted.

One solution for potential caregivers

In Commentary

6:07 am on Mon, 06.17.13

The twins are 89 years old. Health issues signal the end to each living in her own two-bedroom, two-bath condominium. Here's the story of one family's solution: The sisters now live in one unit and home-health services come in. How did they get to this resolution?

Blind fear: Combating terror with eyes wide shut

In Commentary

7:00 am on Thu, 06.13.13

It turns out that the Obama administration has been conducting its own variation of electronic surveillance that the Bush administrated. The problem is not the need to combat terrorism, but the blanket invasion of privacy and the revelation of who the people are who have access to our secrets.

Featured Events:

More About The Beacon Home